a critical edition, in honour of my literature teacher

Beyondwhat just is

One year of Extension Literature, a great many 7:15 am starts, and one very grateful reader.

for Mrs Brooker, from Noah, Class of 2026

psst: like any good text, this page gets better the second time. Tap things.

I. Your name, in theory

Acrostic

An acrostic hides a word in the first letter of each line. Spell out your name and most of the course falls out of it.

  1. BarthesThe birth of the reader must be at the cost of the death of the Author.
  2. RicoeurThe hermeneutic arc: a first guess, then explanation, then understanding.
  3. The ornithorhynchus ruleComplex vocabulary, USED CORRECTLY, will be rewarded.
  4. The OtherLacan, and all sorts of things in this world that act like mirrors.
  5. KristevaEvery text is a mosaic of quotations.
  6. Eagleton“A very readable Marxist critic,” according to your email in May.
  7. RosenblattDid you read efferently, or aesthetically?

Your name is a reading list. Of course it is.

    II. The letter

    Epistolary

    Mrs Brooker

    Reading as

    Reader-centred Reading for what the reader brings to the text.

    Structuralist Reading for the binary oppositions that hold a text’s meaning in place.

    Narratological Reading for who tells the story and who it is told to.

    Deconstructive Caution: deconstruction ahead. Reading for the places where a text’s hierarchies undo themselves.

    Marxist Whose interests are served? Reading for ideology and for who owns the means of production. In this letter, what gets produced is ideas.

    Dear Mrs Brooker,The narratee is named in the first line, and she is also the story’s central character.

    In the past year of Extension Literature, I feel I have somehow learnt and developedA homodiegetic narrator, looking back. The narrating ‘I’ of November reflects on the experiencing ‘I’ of the year before. more as a person and thinker than in the totality of the rest of my schooling. You are the most fantastic teacher, and you have made school something that isn’t simply about the consumption of knowledge,Knowledge as a commodity, made somewhere else and handed down to be consumed. The student is positioned as a consumer, cut off from the means of producing ideas.The first binary opposition: consumption… but rather something that has inspired me, and I’m sure many others,For a moment the narrator speaks for an implied group of students as well as himself.Fish’s interpretive community: readers who share the strategies that make meaning possible. At 7:15 in the morning, twice a week, we were one. to believe that we ourselves can be its creators.This is the turn the letter rests on. The student takes hold of the means of production, and knowledge becomes something they make.…and creation. The letter privileges the second term, and casts the teacher as the one who moves the student from one to the other.Barthes’s ‘birth of the reader’. The reader stops receiving a finished meaning and starts producing one. I wanted to let you know that while my love for technology has never been greater, I’ve decided that I want to study a Bachelor of Philosophy, Policy and Economics instead of Computer Science.A second binary, technology and the liberal arts, framed as a choice of one over the other.The letter announces a choice of one term over another… I truly cannot overstate how much of my desire to study the liberal arts has come from you and your wonderful classes! Our discussions in class have made me think a lot about how I view technology and its use in the world, which is why I’m so interested in research in the AI ethics space.Lévi-Strauss would call this a mediating term. The letter resolves its own opposition by choosing a field that belongs to both sides.…then, in its final clause, returns to the term it left. Technology is what the new degree will study, so the ‘instead of’ doesn’t hold.

    There is a quote from Steve Jobs that I absolutely love! “Life can be much broader once you discover one simple fact: everything around you that you call life was made up by people that were no smarter than you.”Ideology works by making the constructed look natural. The quote denaturalises it: if ‘life’ was made up, it can be made again.An embedded voice. The narrator hands the telling to another speaker and borrows his authority. I share this because it’s an idea that is so true, yet one most people are never exposed to, because they are taught never to think outside of themselves or their pre-existing understanding.Althusser’s ideological state apparatus. School reproduces the existing order by teaching people to accept it as simply the way things are.Iser’s reader brings a repertoire of prior knowledge to every text. These are readers who have never been asked to move past theirs. You have been the antithesis of that,A contradiction inside the apparatus. The institution built to reproduce the order becomes the place where the order is first seen clearly.The letter names its own structure. however, and have opened my eyes to just how much is possible beyond our preconceptions of what is. Teachers like you are so rare,The quote levels everyone: nobody is smarter than you. The letter then raises one person above the rest, building a hierarchy in the same paragraph that pulls one down. The contradiction makes sense, because it takes a rare teacher to convince you that nobody is smarter than you. and I’m so incredibly grateful for all your knowledge and understanding, but most importantly for letting me see what is possible beyond what just is.The governing opposition of the whole text: what is, and what is possible. Every paragraph moves from the first term to the second.‘Possible’ only means something against ‘is’. The privileged term depends on the one it claims to leave behind. I don’t mean to sound like a broken record, but thank you so much!Metanarrative comment: the narrator steps outside the telling to remark on the telling itself.Derrida’s différance: meaning is always deferred to the next word. No single thank you is enough, so the letter says it again.

    Thanks,
    Noah‘The birth of the reader must be at the cost of the death of the Author.’ From here on, the meaning is yours.

    Your course page calls this subject “the study of how we read, rather than what we read.” So, read it again:

    III. A conversation in March

    Dialogue

    In March, I asked you whether AI was any different from a word processor. You told me the difference.

    AI replaces thinking, whereas the word processor merely replaces pen and paper.
    Mrs Brooker, as I wrote it down

    That discussion became my essay, and the essay ended up taking its title from your half of the conversation. In August, you wrote that you would miss our conversations and hearing your opinions about all sorts from AI to Deleuze. The same week, you suggested I could always take a minor in Philosophy to balance all that coding! 😊

    I’m taking the whole degree instead.

    Essay · 27 March 2026 Keep Thinking AI doesn’t threaten thinking. It demands we decide which thinking matters most. Read it on noahmoller.com →

    IV. Brooker, unpacked

    Index cards

    Every task this year came with a page that unpacked it: IA1 Unpacked, IA 2 Unpacked, IA 3 Unpacked, EA Unpacked. Fair’s fair. Here’s yours.

    Start time

    7:15 am

    Two mornings a week. Just a reminder to set your alarms for tomorrow morning!

    Favourite margin word

    discerning

    a discerning Reading and Defence, discerning understanding of theory, the evaluation was discerning.

    Loudest instruction

    PLEASE MAKE SURE THE ISMG IS ATTACHED AND NOT JUST SCREENSHOT!

    Me, 27 February: I just did the unthinkable and submitted my assignment without the ISMG. Sorry.

    Most-repeated request

    Please bring The Dispossessed.

    Three times in one announcement, 17 February.

    Most-asked question

    Hey, whose turn is it to bring snacks?!

    Mine was Friday AM, Week 4, Term 4, 2025.

    Signature

    :-)

    In the announcements. In emails it becomes 😊, as in See you tomorrow 😊

    Currently reading

    10

    books, by my count of your email signatures, from Orlando to The Name of the Rose. They’re on your shelf, below.

    Holiday highlight

    Derrida, in de Beauvoir’s favourite seat

    Five weeks in Europe, and the highlight was reading Specters of Marx in her café in Paris. Sad, I know!

    Best advice

    Limit the rhetorical flourishes.

    Aim for neutral, academic language. IA2 feedback, June. I’m working on it.

    Author of the year

    Mrs Brooker

    The Author is dead. Long live the Author.

    V. The year, as a folktale

    After Propp

    Propp found thirty-one functions in the Russian folktale, always in the same order. Our year used about ten of them, not quite in order.

    Dramatis personae

    The hero
    A Year 12 who thought he wanted to study Computer Science
    The donor
    You
    The magical agent
    Literary Theory: An Anthology, third edition
    The helper
    Whoever was on the snack roster
    The villain
    The semi-colon
    The false hero
    AI, which makes vague, generalised comments
    The dispatcher
    QCAA
    1. Oct 2025
      Initial situation

      What is this extension you speak of?

      Hive 2, Monday morning, 7:15. To think about first: What your favourite text is and What you might include in a definition of ‘Literature’.

    2. Term 1
      Receipt of a magical agent

      Trust me. I’m telling you stories…

      Reader- and author-centred approaches, AKA It’s all about me! and It’s all about the author! Iser, Gadamer, Ricoeur and Fish, Plath’s “Mushrooms”, and our dear friend, Mr Poe.

    3. IA1 · 27 Feb
      The donor tests the hero

      A Reading and Defence of a Poe text

      The Pit and the Pendulum, read as a readerly purgatory, for the journal Reading Edgar Allan Poe.

      Your thorough attention to detail, sophisticated incorporation of theory and evaluation has produced a discerning Reading and Defence.

      You, 19 March, after Derrida’s aporia! in the draft
    4. Term 1
      Villainy, exposed

      Once upon a time…

      Fairy tales and their deconstruction. How harmless are they? What cultural discourses do they conceal? Saussure, Propp, Genette and Derrida on the page; Marx, de Beauvoir, Lacan and Butler around it.

    5. IA2 · 4 Jun
      Transfiguration

      A Complex Transformation and Defence

      The Cobbler’s Helper: The Elves and the Shoemaker, told by an elf, with the clothes as the settlement of a debt.

      I just LOVE this transformation!

      You, in the margin of my draft
    6. Unit 4
      Departure

      Down the rabbit hole…

      Down, down, down. Would the fall never come to an end? Exploration and evaluation, and focus questions, one more time with feeling.

    7. IA3 · 7 Aug
      The difficult task

      An extended academic research paper

      Everyone in the world, no one in the room: Steve Jobs (2015) and the labour of the overlooked, for the journal Shining a Light. Marxism and feminism, and de Beauvoir on your advice.

      This task is a huge undertaking to ace, and you have done a fantastic job!

      You, 11 August, after great title
    8. 14 Oct
      Return

      The last class. Ever!

      Unbelievably, we have come to that time – and it always comes so fast. I will bring some biscuits or cake.

    9. EA · 10 Nov
      Struggle

      The Final Countdown

      One unseen text out of three, and two hours to write about it. If in doubt, say “the text”. Nail the semi-colon or let it go.

      See? I told you that you could do it! Whoop! 😊 SO much better!

      You, on my practice essay, 16 September
    10. 20 Nov
      Wedding

      Graduation

      Propp’s tales end with a wedding. This one ends with a graduation, and a letter.

    VI. A small glossary

    Performative

    Tap a term and it does what it says.

    VII. Two shelves

    Ours, and yours

    The first shelf is what we read this year. The second is what you were reading while we did, according to the line under your name in every email: I am currently reading…

    Ours: what we read
    Yours: what you were reading

    with Foucault’s cat, disrupting the discursive binary of inside or outside

    Catalogue card

    Pull a book off either shelf

    Every book has a card.

    VIII. Epilogue

    Fin

    Fin.

    Every text has to end somewhere. When ours ended, you made the class photo your new wallpaper. My new wallpaper 😊

    Thank you, Mrs Brooker.